
On October 27, the two most widely cited repeat-sales home price indexes came out a few hours apart.
The S&P Cotality Case-Shiller National Index said prices rose 2.1% in the year to August. On the month they fell 0.2%, or rose 0.3%, depending on whether you use the seasonally adjusted version.
The FHFA House Price Index said prices rose 2.4% over the year and 0.3% in August.
In its September report, the National Association of Realtors put the median existing-home price at $417,500, up 1.3% from a year ago. And HousingWire's weekly listing data put the median asking price at $430,000 for the week ending October 23, down 2.1% from a year ago.
So prices are up 2.4%, 2.1% or 1.3%, or down 2.1%. A seller reads the first number, a buyer reads the last, and both come away sure of what the market is doing. Here is what each one actually counts.
What each index counts
Case-Shiller: the same houses, sold twice. Case-Shiller is a repeat-sales index. It tracks homes that sold more than once and measures how much each one's price changed. That means a month full of mansion sales doesn't push it up. Each headline reading is a three-month moving average of closings, and it is published with a lag of about two months. The "August" number released October 27 mostly reflects deals that went under contract in the spring and early summer.
FHFA: the same method, a narrower set of loans. FHFA also uses repeat sales, but its flagship index uses only purchase loans backed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. That leaves out cash purchases, jumbo loans and most FHA and VA loans. It is the best measure of the conforming-loan middle of the market and a weaker one for the top end and for cash-heavy markets.
NAR median: the middle sale, whatever sold. The median is the price in the middle of all existing-home sales that closed in the month. It is current, but it moves with the mix. If more expensive homes sell in a given month, the median rises even when no individual home gained value. NAR said August and September were the two slowest months for sales this year, at about a 3.99 million annual pace in September. With that few sales, small changes in the mix can move the median.
List prices: what sellers are asking. Asking prices are the earliest signal because they change before contracts are signed, and the furthest from settled values. A falling median list price can mean sellers are cutting prices, or that more modest homes are coming on the market. Either way, it shows where the next round of closings is heading.
Put them in time order and they mostly agree. The lagging repeat-sales indexes show prices up a bit over 2%. The more current median shows a bit over 1%. The leading asking-price data shows a decline. The market is cooling, and each measure catches it at a different stage.
The number that settles it: inflation
The Bureau of Labor Statistics put consumer inflation at 3.4% for August. Compare that with Case-Shiller's 2.1% and the typical home lost about 1.3% in real value over the year.
Cotality's principal economist Thomas Malone said it plainly: "When adjusted for inflation, home prices have been mostly flat since 2022, and sales turnover remains at lows last seen during the Great Recession." His explanation: "seller lock-in — with record equity and low mortgage rates, homeowners have little incentive to move unless they receive an exceptional offer. It also reflects weak underlying demand."
So all four numbers say the same thing in different units: nominal prices are roughly flat to slightly up, and real prices are falling.
The national number isn't yours anyway
The spread inside each index is bigger than the gap between them.
Case-Shiller, 20 metros: Chicago +6.7% (sixth straight month leading), New York +6.2%, Cleveland +4.3%. Seattle −2.0%, Las Vegas −1.3%, Denver −0.8%, Dallas −0.8%, Tampa −0.4%. Detroit was not reported for August, so 19 metros have readings.
FHFA, nine census divisions: annual changes ranged from +0.5% in the Mountain states to +4.4% in the East North Central states (Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, Wisconsin).
Month to month, only Chicago and Miami rose in August on Case-Shiller. Seattle fell 1.1%, and Los Angeles and Dallas fell 0.8% each.
The pattern holds across both indexes. Midwest and Northeast markets are still rising. Mountain and West Coast metros are flat or falling. If you live in Ohio or Seattle, the national number is a poor guide to your home's value.
Seasonal adjustment
Case-Shiller's headline index is not seasonally adjusted. Home prices normally rise in spring and soften after summer. S&P's Rebecca Kaufman noted that in August the unadjusted national index fell 0.2% while the seasonally adjusted version rose 0.3%: "The divergence suggests that the typical post-summer slowdown is obscuring some underlying strength."
Between now and February, unadjusted indexes will tend to show monthly declines because of the season. A headline saying "prices fell for the third straight month" in December may describe nothing more than winter. Check the seasonally adjusted series before drawing a conclusion.
Cost of buying: a third measure
Price is half of what a buyer pays. The other half is the rate. Freddie Mac's 30-year average was 7.24% on October 29, down from 7.32% the week before, but up from 6.17% a year earlier.
On NAR's September median of $417,500 with 20% down, that difference works out like this:
At 6.17%: about $2,039 a month in principal and interest
At 7.24%: about $2,276 a month
That is $237 more a month, about $2,845 a year, for a house whose price rose 1.3%. For a buyer, the monthly payment moved about as much as the price did.
That is the other half of Malone's lock-in point. An owner with a 3% or 4% loan who sells and buys again faces the payment gap twice, so fewer people sell. With fewer sellers, inventory stays tight enough to keep nominal prices from falling much, even as real values slip.
What to use, depending on your decision
If you're selling: use recent closed sales on your own street or subdivision, and adjust them with your metro's FHFA or Case-Shiller trend. Ignore the national figure. If local asking prices are falling, price to the closings, not to the listings.
If you're buying: use the list-price trend and days on market in your metro to judge how much room you have to negotiate. NAR's chief economist Lawrence Yun said "higher inventory and lengthening days on market give buyers improved negotiating power."
If you're contesting a property tax assessment: assessors usually work from sales a year or more old. In a metro where repeat-sales indexes are negative, like Seattle, Las Vegas, Denver or Dallas, a valuation that assumes last year's trend continued may be too high. Bring the index.
If you own rentals or lend against homes: underwrite on real values. A 2% nominal gain against 3.4% inflation is a loss in purchasing power, even if the loan-to-value ratio looks fine.
The case against
The real-value decline is small, and nominal prices are holding. FHFA's index rose in both July and August, and the September median marked another annual increase. A market that has absorbed a rise in rates from about 6.2% to over 7% with prices still up in nominal terms is showing resilience, not weakness. Kaufman's point about seasonal adjustment also cuts the other way: underlying monthly momentum was positive in August.
Listing data also overstates weakness in a slow market. As inventory builds, more modest homes come on the market, and that can pull the median asking price down without any single home losing value.
The 90-day marker (tracked)
Claim: The Case-Shiller release for November 2026 data, scheduled for late January 2027, will show at least six of the reported metros with year-over-year price declines, up from five (Seattle, Las Vegas, Denver, Dallas, Tampa) in August.
Stated confidence: 60% · Verification date: S&P Cotality Case-Shiller release, late January 2027 · Status: OPEN
What would make us wrong: mortgage rates fall fast enough this fall to pull buyers back before year-end, or the western metros bottom out, leaving the count at five or fewer.
Correction (Nov. 7): As first published, this marker said four metros were down year over year in August and set the bar at five. S&P’s own table showed five (Tampa, −0.4%, was the fifth), so the original bar had already been met. We have restated the claim at six. The original wording stays on our tracker and is scored as a baseline error.
Want your market checked?
This newsletter is the free version of what I do: take the number everyone is quoting, rebuild it from the source, and show whether it fits your situation.
If you have a valuation, an assessment, or a "prices are up X%" claim about your market, reply with it. I'll tell you which index applies, what it leaves out, and what I couldn't verify.
cokas.io — no sales call, ever.
Know someone deciding whether to list this winter? Forward them this one. They can get the next edition free at thepatternbrief.com.
Every prediction in The Pattern Brief carries a verification date and is revisited in a future edition, including this one.
Sources
HousingWire, Oct 27, 2026: Case-Shiller national +2.1% y/y, −0.2% NSA / +0.3% SA m/m, 10- and 20-city composites, metro rankings, Malone and Kaufman quotes, August CPI 3.4%, HousingWire Data median list price $430,000 (−2.1% y/y)
S&P Dow Jones Indices, Oct 27, 2026: Case-Shiller August 2026 release
FHFA, Oct 27, 2026: +0.3% m/m, +2.4% y/y, census-division range, purchase-only Fannie/Freddie methodology
NAR, September 2026 Existing-Home Sales summary: median $417,500, +1.3% y/y, 3.99 million SAAR; Yun quote via FedPrimeRate.com summary
Freddie Mac PMMS, Oct 29, 2026: 30-year 7.24%, 7.32% prior week, 6.17% a year earlier
Payment math by The Pattern Brief: $334,000 loan, 30-year fixed, principal and interest only
